The Rose Clean Stock Program
A guide to Foundation Plant Services virus testing and elimination methods for establishing foundation rose propagating stock
History of the FPS Rose Collection
The FPS rose collection was established during the 1960s by Dr. George Nyland, a UC Davis plant pathologist. Nyland was convinced that rose mosaic disease was a problem in roses that needed to be addressed by a program of virus testing and heat therapy for virus elimination. When he found that an important cultivar was infected with rose mosaic, Nyland employed recently developed virus elimination techniques; propagating from plants that were grown at 100°F until he was able to find a healthy version of the cultivar. This work lead to the establishment of a virus-tested collection at UC Davis. Budwood from these plants was made available to nurseries and growers to serve as a source of propagating stock. Throughout his career, and even after his retirement in 1985, George Nyland was a tireless advocate of virus-tested planting stock for rose nursery propagation.
By the early 1990s, the FPS rose collection was in need of repropagation and retesting. At that time, Mike Cunningham, FPS rose program manager, was concerned that the plants were aging and less productive, that many of the newer cultivars were not in the collection, and that the plants had not been retested for virus in many years. Cunningham began working closely with the garden rose nursery industry to find funding for this work. His efforts led to planting a new foundation rose collection in 1995, which has become an important resource for nurseries and growers throughout the United States as a reliable source of clean budwood of many major rose cultivars. The current collection covers eight acres and includes more than 538 rose scion and seven understock cultivars. Each year new cultivars are added to the collection after virus testing and, if necessary, virus elimination treatment.
The FPS rose collection covers eight acres - the largest public collection of virus-tested roses in the United States.
Overview of the FPS Rose Program from New Selection to Commercial Distribution
1. New introductions, called “candidate selections,” are typically sent to FPS as dormant, bareroot plants. Candidate selections may originate as AARS winners, advanced selections of a rose hybridizer, or the proprietary selection of a commercial rose nursery. There is also a growing interest in bringing historic or “heritage” roses into the program to ensure that they are available free of rose mosaic. After potting and labeling, plants are placed outdoors at the FPS nursery to grow under ambient conditions.
2. Disease testing for viral pathogens is the first step for inclusion of a candidate selection into the collection. In March and April, samples of young leaf tissue from the candidate plants are tested by the Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA), a serological test conducted in the laboratory. Then, after the first flowering, mature budwood from each candidate rose is graft-inoculated onto both Shirofugen cherry and Burr multiflora rose for biological indexing. Combining the results of these tests gives a greater accuracy for virus detection than relying on any single test. Two to three years are required to complete all tests.
3. When initial testing demonstrates that a rose cultivar is infected with a viral pathogen, heat therapy or tissue culture procedures are begun for virus elimination. All tissue culture selections and plants that were propagated from heat-treated buds must undergo complete ELISA, Shirofugen cherry and multiflora indexing to determine whether the virus elimination treatment was successful. (Details in Virus Elimination Therapies). Once the ELISA, Shirofugen cherry, and the first year of multiflora tests are negative, rooted cuttings of the candidate selection are propagated in FPS greenhouses in preparation for establishment in the field collection. During the second spring after the inoculation, the multiflora indicator plants are reinspected.
4. Only when the candidate selection is found negative for virus by each testing method are the rooted cuttings finally planted in the FPS rose collection. Whenever possible, new introductions are planted as cuttings on their own roots to reduce the possibility of introducing virus through an infected understock and to prevent the problems associated with rootstock suckering. The FPS rose collection is regularly retested by ELISA for reoccurrence of virus. The plants are also visually inspected in the spring for virus symptoms. As the selections mature, the rose collection is carefully examined for correct identification and trueness to type. FPS holds regular meetings with professional rose propagators and breeders who inspect the collection. Any selection that is not up to standard is rogued out. If questions arise about the identity or productivity of a selection, it is flagged in the computer database, restricting distribution until a conclusive determination is made by industry representatives. The quality of the rose program is enhanced as the rose production industry reports back on its experience with the plant materials originating from the FPS rose program.
5. Dormant budwood is cut and shipped from the FPS rose collection in early November. Cuttings are distributed in 9-, 18-, or 27-inch lengths. After labeling and bundling, the dormant budwood is kept in cold storage until shipped or picked up. Leafy cuttings of scion and understock varieties can be harvested upon request during the summer months for green propagation by customers.
Currently, FPS utilizes biological indexes, serological tests and DNA tests to determine the presence of virus pathogens in rose cultivars. Used extensively to check for virus in plants prior to inclusion in the FPS rose collection, they are also offered on a fee-for-service basis to private customers.
Biological Indexes Biological indexes have been used for decades to detect rose viruses. Various sensitive “indicator” plants are inoculated with buds of candidate plants, and the indicators are then monitored for disease symptoms. The development of symptoms on the indicator means that the candidate was virus infected. Indicator varieties are chosen for their ability to display relatively rapid, distinct disease symptoms when infected. Biological tests for rose viruses are very reliable, but they may require up to three years before results are obtained. Two biological tests used at FPS for rose viruses are the Shirofugen cherry index and the Rosa multiflora (Burr) field index.
Multiflora Field Index
At FPS, Rosa multiflora (Burr) understock is used as an indicator variety for the detection of rose mosaic, rose spring dwarf and rose yellow mosaic. The field procedure requires at least two growing seasons. This indexing procedure can also be performed in a single season in the greenhouse under tightly controlled conditions for light and temperature. Symptom observations require some degree of interpretation, as abnormalities in plant growth may be caused by environmental factors as well as viral pathogens. To conduct this field test, buds from a candidate variety of unknown disease status are T-budded into the growing branches or trunk of multiflora canes that were stuck in the field and rooted the previous fall. Two multiflora indicator plants are used to test each candidate rose bush. Each of the two indicator plants receives three buds from the candidate, for a total of six candidate buds. Approximately two weeks after budding, the candidate buds are inspected to determine if they are alive - virus transmission is reduced if buds die, and the inoculation may need to be repeated. The indicator plants are visually inspected for mosaic type symptoms several times during the early spring following inoculation. Symptoms may include vein clearing, ringspots, line patterns, mosaics, and leaf distortion and puckering. Symptoms are most clearly expressed in March and April, fading dramatically as seasonal daytime temperatures increase.
Laboratory Tests for Disease
Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA) is a sensitive and rapid laboratory serological method for detecting viruses. To develop an ELISA assay for a particular virus, a specific antibody to the virus is required. Tissue is taken from the plant to be tested (usually the leaf or cambial scrapings) and ground in a buffer solution. This sample from the test plant is pipetted into the wells of a plastic microtiter plate which has previously been incubated with the specific virus antibody. If the sample contains virus, it will be captured by the antibody. After rinsing, another virusspecific antibody conjugated to an enzyme is bound to the captured virus. Finally, a clear substrate buffer, specific to the enzyme, is added. Color change in the final substrate buffer solution is the result of binding of the viral antigens in the plant material to the antibodies, and indicates a positive response. Completion of the test requires only two days; however, plant samples must be collected at specific seasons to obtain accurate results. ELISA technology is sensitive, but its scope is limited to detecting viruses for which antibodies are available. FPS laboratory staff routinely uses ELISA to test roses for prunus necrotic ringspot virus (PNRSV), apple mosaic virus (ApMV), arabis mosaic virus (ArMV) and prune dwarf virus (PDV).
PCR DNA tests rely on knowledge of the genome of a pathogen such as a plant virus. Most promising is Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR), which involves the selective amplification, using enzymes, of a small part of the virus’ genome or unique genetic code. If the virus is present in a plant sample, even in very low amounts, the amplification steps in PCR allow for its detection. It is this amplification that makes PCR such a sensitive test. PCR only detects specific viruses, but it is much more sensitive than ELISA in most cases. FPS laboratory staff are exploring the use of PCR for testing roses for PNRSV, ApMV, ArMV and PDV; however, the process is more expensive than ELISA and currently only used in special circumstances.
Plant samples are ground in buffer solution for ELISA and PCR tests. Below: An ELISA plate loaded by pipette with virus antibody. Color changes in the ELISA plate indicate a positive result. Right: A pipette is used to load PCR product from plant samples onto an agarose gel. An electric current is used to move the PCR products across the gel where they separate according to size. This creates banding patterns in the gel which can be used to identify viral pathogens.
FPS Virus Tests for Roses Biological Indexes Shirofugen cherry and Rosa multiflora (Burr) for detection of: Rose mosaic disease Rose spring dwarf disease Rose yellow mosaic disease Serological (ELISA) for detection of: Prunus necrotic ringspot virus (PNRSV) Apple mosaic virus (ApMV) Arabis mosaic virus (ArMV) Prune dwarf virus (PDV) Tomato ringspot virus (ToRSV)* Strawberry latent ringspot virus (SLRSV)* Nucleic Acid (PCR) for detection of: Prunus necrotic ringspot virus (PNRSV)* Apple mosaic virus (ApMV)* Arabis mosaic virus (ArMV)* Prune dwarf virus (PDV)* *denotes experimental use only, not regularly performed on the FPS rose collection.
Virus Elimination Therapies
An ounce of prevention is invaluable compared to a cure when the subject is rose viruses. There is no “cure” for an individual plant once it is infected; however, it is possible to “clean up” a variety, ie., eliminate the virus from the propagating stock. Two possible techniques for eliminating virus from an infected variety are heat therapy and tissue culture. Heat therapy Heat therapy has been used for many decades at FPS to treat virus-infected rose cultivars and create new foundation stock for the collection. In the heat therapy process, potted bushes of rose cultivars infected with virus are subjected to constant 100°F temperatures in a heat chamber. The condition of each plant in the heat chamber is checked on a weekly basis. Budsticks are removed from the plants as they begin to show the effects of the heat. Many propagations are made, each with an increasing number of days of heat therapy.
Maintenance of the rose plant for four weeks or longer at 100°F is optimal for elimination of rose mosaic virus. Rose selections that cannot tolerate such a high temperature may begin to deteriorate quickly and budwood is removed soonerâ€”sometimes as early as two weeks. Healthy propagation wood may be obtained even with the shorter period of heat therapy, since viral pathogens are not uniformly distributed within the plant, and buds might be cut that, by chance, have not been infected. The heat-treated plant material is budded onto Rosa multiflora (Burr) understock, which is used simultaneously as understock and as an indicator for disease. The multiflora rootstock will support the bud and, if virus is present in the bud, will develop symptoms of rose mosaic disease. Symptoms are initially observed the spring following a summer’s heat treatment work. This allows time for the bud to heal and virus (if present) to move into the multiflora. Indexing for the viruses in rose plants propagated from heattreated buds is repeated several times, as one test may not always detect the presence of virus. After the final observations, multiflora plants that have no observed virus symptoms are pruned back to the heattreated buds. This encourages growth of the heat-treated cultivar, which is itself monitored for virus symptoms. Multiflora suckers are not removed entirely, and are observed for symptoms again in the spring. When the buds of the heat-treated cultivar have grown out and matured sufficiently, budwood is taken and indexed on Shirofugen cherry trees. In addition, leaf tissue is taken from the new growth for ELISA testing for apple mosaic virus, arabis mosaic virus, and prunus necrotic ringspot virus. The heat therapy is considered successful only when the ELISA test, and Shirofugen cherry and multiflora indexes are all negative for virus. The heat-treated scion cultivar is then propagated by rooting leafy cuttings or by budding onto a healthy understock.
Tissue culture therapy is an alternative virus elimination technique successfully used with many horticultural crops. At FPS, heat treatment for virus elimination has been replaced or supplemented by shoot-tip tissue culture therapy for grapevines, strawberries and sweet potatoes. Virus elimination is normally achieved in 90-100 percent of plants that are cultured using our procedures. FPS researchers are now working on an experimental basis to optimize rose shoot-tip culture. A shoot tip, essentially a meristematic dome surrounded by a few leaf primordia, is cut from the virusinfected selection. The meristematic tissue has a unique potential to regenerate a new plant with a minimum chance of mutation, or genetic change, in comparison to plants derived from other tissues. A shoot tip length in the range of 0.2-1.0 mm is normally small enough to eliminate virus in other crops. It is not known exactly why virus is eliminated, but from a practical point of view, the smaller the explant (the part of a plant used to start an in vitro culture) which can be cultured, the greater the chance of eliminating virus. Unfortunately, the smaller the explant, the more difficult it is to regenerate a plant. The shoot tip is excised under sterile conditions and placed on a special gelatinous mixture - a growth medium - inside a sterile test tube. These cultures are then maintained in a growth chamber which provides controlled growing conditions during the critical establishment phase. Depending on the needs of the plant species, several transfers may be made to specialized media for shoot growth, rooting, etc. Once well developed, plants are transferred into soil, acclimated to normal light and air, moved into greenhouses and screen houses and, finally, to outdoor conditions. FPS has successfully produced a few rose plants using shoot-tip culture from virus-infected selections. Although there are some difficulties to overcome, it is hoped that this technique becomes routine for roses as FPS conducts further research and gains experience. If successful, this would greatly increase the availability of virus-free roses throughout the United States.
Ordering Rose Materials and Services
Rose scion budwood and understock canes from the FPS disease-tested collection may be purchased for propagation purposes. Because the FPS program is designed to put virus-tested stock into the hands of professional propagators, sales are made primarily to the rose nursery industry in order to establish healthy sources of propagation materials at the production level. Rose enthusiasts benefit indirectly from the FPS program when nurseries use disease-tested stock to produce plants of improved disease status for retail sale. Propagating material is available in the form of unrooted dormant and green cuttings. FPS does not sell rooted plants. Orders must be received by October 15 of each year to be included in the November allocation. Material can also be requested from late spring through early fall on a first-come, first-serve basis. Custom rose virus testing and/or virus elimination services employing the protocols described above are available from FPS on a fee-for-service basis by contract with the University of California.